Oxidation and fermentation both are used by organisms to extract energy from molecules. These operate in distinct ways and under different conditions. Here's the comparison.
Oxidation vs. Fermentation - Overview
Feature | Oxidation | Fermentation |
Oxygen | Typically required | Not required (anaerobic) |
Energy Yield | High | Low |
Breakdown | Complete (ideally) | Incomplete |
End Products | CO2, H2O (ideally) | Ethanol, Lactic Acid, Acetic Acid, etc. |
Examples | Burning, Rusting, Cellular Respiration | Brewing, Yogurt production, Muscle Fatigue |
Oxidation: Taking Electrons, Releasing Energy
In oxidation, a molecule loses electrons. These are taken up by another molecule, which is then said to be reduced. This electron transfer is a duo; oxidation and reduction are together called the redox reaction.
Key Characteristics
Requires Oxygen
While not always a strict requirement, oxidation often involves the combination of a substance with oxygen. The "oxidizing agent" is the molecule accepting the electron or facilitating the loss of electrons from the oxidized molecule.
High Energy Yield: Oxidation reactions typically release a significant amount of energy. This is because the breakdown of molecules is often more complete in the presence of oxygen, extracting more potential energy.
Complete Breakdown (Ideally): In the ideal scenario, oxidation breaks down organic molecules (like glucose) into simpler inorganic molecules like carbon dioxide and water.
Examples of Oxidation
Burning Wood: This is a classic example. The wood (primarily cellulose) reacts with oxygen in the air, releasing heat and light, and forming ash, carbon dioxide, and water.
Rusting Iron: Iron reacts with oxygen and water in the air, forming iron oxide (rust). This slow oxidation process weakens the iron over time.
Cellular Respiration (with Oxygen): This is how our bodies get energy from food. Glucose is oxidized in the presence of oxygen, producing energy (ATP), carbon dioxide, and water. This efficient process fuels our cells' activities. (This is sometimes called "aerobic respiration".)
An example is cutting an apple, and it quickly turns brown. The browning is oxidation in action, as the enzyme polyphenol oxidase (PPO) reacts with oxygen to create the brown pigment melanin.
Oxidation affects how the apple looks and can also change its flavor and nutritional value, causing loss of vitamin C. This reaction is inhibited by citric acid.
Oxidation is common to biological systems. In cellular respiration glucose converts to energy and produces carbon dioxide and water as by-products. This reaction is fundamental for many living organisms.
Fermentation
Fermentation happens without the presence of oxygen. It's a way for organisms to generate energy when oxygen is scarce or unavailable. Yeast, for instance, creates ATP in aerobic conditions and alcohol in anaerobic.
Key Characteristics
Anaerobic Process: Fermentation occurs in the absence of oxygen.
Lower Energy Yield: Compared to oxidation, fermentation produces significantly less energy. This is because the breakdown of molecules is incomplete.
Incomplete Breakdown: Instead of completely breaking down organic molecules into carbon dioxide and water, fermentation results in the production of other organic molecules.
These can be ethanol, lactic acid, or acetic acid. The type of molecule produced depends on the organism and the specific biochemical pathway used.
Examples of Fermentation
Yeast Fermentation (Alcoholic Fermentation): Yeast converts sugars like glucose into ethanol and carbon dioxide. This is the basis of brewing beer, making wine, and baking bread.
Lactic Acid Fermentation: This occurs in muscles during intense activity when oxygen supply limited. Glucose is broken down into lactic acid, which provides an energy spike.
Lactic acidosis is too much lactic acid in the system, with symptoms from muscle fatigue to heart attack. Lactic acid bacteria use fermentation to make yogurt, fermented green beans and sauerkraut.
In yogurt making, lactic acid bacteria convert lactose, the sugar in milk, into lactic acid. This process gives yogurt its distinct tangy flavor and creamy texture. The absence of oxygen is crucial lactic acid bacteria are anaerobic.
Acetic Acid Fermentation: Acetic acid bacteria ferment ethanol into acetic acid, the main component of vinegar.
Fermentation even extends beyond food. It significantly contributes to biogas production, where organic waste decays anaerobically, generating energy for heating or electricity.
Fermentation is Ancient: Fermentation is one of the oldest methods of food preservation, dating back thousands of years. Evidence of fermented beverages c. 7000 BCE is found in China.
Digestive Microbiome: Fermentation occurs in the human GI tract. Bacteria ferment undigested carbohydrates, producing short-chain fatty acids.
Flavor Development: Culinary experts often apply controlled oxidation to enhance flavors. Olive oil develops a richer taste profile over time and oxidation is a major phase of tea production.
Non-Fiction Books:
Fiction Books:
READ: Lora Ley Adventures - Germanic Mythology Fiction Series
READ: Reiker For Hire - Victorian Detective Murder Mysteries